Opens in a new tab

Plumbing

Water Heater Efficiency Tips: What Actually Helps

By Tom Darling

Owner · City of Albany Master Plumber · Lic. #PLBG21-147

Updated

Empire State Plumbing technician connecting copper piping on a Bradford White water heater and boiler system in a Capital Region mechanical room

The short answer

What homeowners should know first

The most useful water-heater efficiency steps are not a universal list of tricks. They depend on the type and condition of the heater, household hot-water demand, control settings, recirculation, distribution losses, water quality, and whether the equipment is due for repair or replacement. Begin with safety and the manufacturer's instructions. Then reduce avoidable hot-water use and losses before assuming that a new appliance will deliver a particular savings percentage.

Water heater efficiency tips: how to improve water heater efficiency

If you are working out how to make a water heater more efficient, these are the steps that usually matter most, in the order worth trying. Each is explained in the numbered sections below, and every one depends on your exact equipment and your household.

  • Fix leaks first. A dripping hot tap or a weeping fitting wastes the water and the energy that heated it.
  • Check the temperature setting against the manual. A setting near 120°F is a common starting point for households with no special needs; a higher setting raises standby loss and scald risk.
  • Insulate accessible hot-water pipe where the clearances allow, and never cover controls, labels, valves, venting or the relief valve.
  • Keep up the maintenance in the manual, such as flushing a tank on schedule and checking the anode rod.
  • Cut hot-water waste with low-flow fixtures, shorter showers and fewer repeated small draws.
  • Use the away setting on a long trip when the model has one; see water heater vacation mode.
  • When it is time to replace, compare ratings (ENERGY STAR and the EnergyGuide label) and size the new unit to the household.

1. Confirm the equipment and operating mode

Identify whether the home uses a storage tank, tankless unit, heat-pump water heater, boiler-connected system, or another design. Record fuel or power source, model, capacity, control type, recirculation, and maintenance history.

Operating modes are model-specific. A heat-pump water heater, for example, may offer efficiency, hybrid, electric, or vacation settings with different recovery behavior. A gas or electric storage tank may use a dial or electronic setpoint. Follow the exact manual; do not copy a setting from another model.

Heat pump water heater in a basement beside a laundry sink and wood wall

2. Address hot-water waste first

Leaks at faucets, showers, fixtures, piping, or hot-water equipment waste both water and the energy used to heat it. Repair the verified leak rather than compensating by raising the temperature or changing schedules.

Fixtures and usage also matter. Appropriate WaterSense-labeled products can reduce water use while meeting performance criteria. Household behavior—long showers, repeated small draws, or running hot water while waiting—can outweigh a minor equipment adjustment.

3. Review temperature safely

Higher water temperature can increase standby and distribution losses and raise scald risk. Lower settings can affect usable capacity, hygiene strategy, appliance performance, and some system designs. There is no responsible one-number instruction for every building.

A qualified review should consider the manufacturer’s allowed range, local requirements, occupants who may be vulnerable to scalding, mixing valves, distribution temperature, recirculation, and water-quality considerations. Never use a touch test as a temperature measurement.

4. Reduce distribution losses where appropriate

Heat can be lost between the heater and fixtures. Accessible hot-water piping may benefit from correctly selected and installed insulation, subject to clearances from flues, burners, electrical components, and manufacturer restrictions. Do not cover controls, labels, valves, venting, relief devices, or prohibited parts of the appliance.

Long pipe runs and poor routing also increase wait time and wasted water. A recirculation system can improve convenience, but continuous circulation can increase heat loss and pump energy. Controls that match actual use may help, depending on the plumbing design.

5. Maintain the exact system⁠—not a generic checklist

Storage tanks, tankless heat exchangers, heat-pump filters, anode rods, condensate systems, combustion components, and water-treatment equipment have different requirements. Sediment or scale can affect operation, but a generic flushing instruction can be unsafe or unsuitable for neglected, damaged, or unfamiliar equipment.

Use the manufacturer schedule and document what was actually found. Maintenance cannot repair a leaking tank, unsafe venting, damaged wiring, failed controls, or an incorrectly designed installation.

6. Compare replacement options with the whole home in view

When replacement is justified, compare first-hour or delivery capacity, household demand, available fuel and electrical service, venting, condensate, space, noise, air volume and temperature for heat-pump models, and installation scope. The yellow EnergyGuide label and standardized efficiency information help compare models, but actual use still depends on the home and occupants.

Do not assume the highest-rated appliance is automatically the right fit. A heat-pump water heater may need adequate space, air conditions, condensate management, and electrical capacity. A tankless system must be sized for required flow and temperature rise. A storage tank must meet demand without unsafe temperature workarounds.

For a documented equipment comparison, review efficient water-heater installation options based on demand, site conditions, and the full installation scope.

Electric water heater efficiency and gas water heater efficiency: where the losses are

An ordinary electric tank turns almost all of the electricity it uses into heat, so the big levers are standby loss, the temperature setting and how much hot water the household draws. A heat pump water heater moves heat from the surrounding air instead of making all of it with heating elements, which is why ENERGY STAR certified heat pump models use less electricity than a conventional electric tank, provided the space, condensate drain and electrical service suit them.

On a gas tank, venting, combustion air and the condition of the burner matter as much as the setting. A service visit checks them, along with the anode rod and the relief valve; see water heater repair if the unit is noisy, slow to recover or not heating as it used to. If you are deciding between fuels for a replacement, read gas vs electric water heater.

How to verify whether a change helped

Use comparable utility periods, actual fuel or electricity use, weather and occupancy context, and any equipment-specific monitoring available. A lower bill alone is not proof if rates, weather, occupancy, or usage changed. Record the change date and compare enough time to avoid judging one unusual week.

Safety limits

Do not open fuel-burning or energized equipment, bypass controls, block venting, alter a relief valve, or insulate against manufacturer instructions. Do not restore power to an electric storage heater unless it is completely full. If you smell gas, suspect combustion trouble, encounter wet electrical equipment, or receive a carbon-monoxide alarm, leave the area and follow emergency and utility guidance.

Sources used for this guide

  1. U.S. Department of Energy, Water Heating
  2. U.S. Department of Energy, Heat Pump Water Heaters
  3. ENERGY STAR, Water Heaters
  4. A. O. Smith, Water Heater Maintenance Guide

Questions homeowners ask

Not as a universal instruction. It can affect standby loss, but the appropriate setting depends on equipment, scald protection, hygiene, capacity, occupants, and local requirements.

No. Newer tanks may already be well insulated, and some manufacturers restrict added insulation. Never cover controls, warnings, valves, venting, or required clearances.

Efficiency and operating cost depend on the exact models, fuel or electricity rates, demand, distribution, installation, and maintenance. Compare standardized ratings and the whole project.

Look for an ENERGY STAR certified model. Electric heat pump water heaters use less electricity than conventional electric water heaters because they move heat instead of making it.

Ask your utility companies whether any programs apply to your address. Availability changes.

It can reduce standby heat loss and scald risk, but how much it helps depends on the unit and how much hot water the household uses, and the setting still has to follow the manual and the needs of everyone in the home. If you are unsure which setting is right, ask a plumber to check the setup.

Fix leaks, set the temperature carefully, insulate accessible hot-water pipe, and maintain the tank on the manual’s schedule. When you replace it, a heat pump water heater with an ENERGY STAR label uses less electricity than a conventional electric tank, if the space, condensate drain and electrical service suit it.

Sediment at the bottom of a tank can make the burner or element work harder, so flushing on the manual’s schedule helps the unit run as designed. It does not repair a leaking tank or a failed part. See how often to flush a water heater for timing and the usual steps.

Not on efficiency alone. Replacement makes sense when the unit is failing, leaking or past its working life, and a newer, better-rated model can then lower standby loss. If it still works, leaks, settings and maintenance come first. The signs you need a new water heater list when that point has come; replacement and installation follows.

Related services

Written for Capital Region homeowners by Tom Darling.

Recommendations depend on the home, equipment, measurements, current codes, and manufacturer instructions.

Call Monday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm, or book online any time.

Need a professional assessment?

Efficient water-heater installation options

Keep reading

Need help? Efficient water-heater installation options

Empire State Plumbing has served Capital Region homeowners since 2006 — licensed (City of Albany #PLBG21-147) and insured. Call Monday–Friday, 7:30am–6pm, or book online any time.

Real homeowners

What Capital Region homeowners say

Verified Google reviews from Capital Region homeowners.

Power-vent gas water heater on a concrete floor in front of reflective insulation